Accepting the end of ASOIAF
Closure from smut fanfiction after thirteen years

This post assumes some familiarity with A Song of Ice and Fire and includes spoilers.
I was 12 years old when I finished A Dance with Dragons for the first time. In retrospect this was maybe not the most age-appropriate reading material, but let’s lay that aside. I remember laying the book down after the final chapter, buzzing with excitement about all the new plot threads that had just been introduced and how it would all come together for the conclusion of the series.
Since then I have finished intermediate school, graduated high school, obtained a four-year engineering degree, and spent another four years as a working professional. I am still waiting for The Winds of Winter. And Winds is not even the last book of the series: at least one more, provisionally titled A Dream of Spring, will be required to wrap everything up.
There has been a steady drip of news over the years, enough that it’s possible to delude yourself that GRRM’s Winds will one day be published. A chapter reading here, a blog post there, dispatches from the mountain being worn away by a chisel.
And then there’s the TV show. I distinctly remember Season 6, when the show finally had to strike out into unknown territory beyond the published books. This concluded with the travesty of Season 8. But there was always the awareness that the showrunners had been in contact with GRRM, that many of these plot points were taken from the outlines of the final books; they were just shown to us through a distorted mirror, warped by the omissions and pressures of the show.
Every few years I return to the forums and the subreddits to catch up on the latest analysis and theorising. Reading these is incredibly fun because of all the above factors:
There’s a substantial population of people like me who grew up with the series and then were left adrift.
We’re most of the way through the series but have had over a decade to speculate about the conclusion.
GRRM really has foreshadowed plot developments with subtle clues in earlier books. Small thematic details usually are intentional and important.
The TV show provides clues about events we can expect to happen without the surrounding context. They happen seemingly at random; it’s easy to tell that something like Bran becoming king is a plot point from the books, but how the books will arrive there is left as an exercise for the reader.
GRRM has procrastinated on finishing the series by producing a lot of background material that informs speculation about the ASOIAF ending.
It’s fun in the same way that conspiracy theories are, except it doesn’t alienate you from society and you actually aren’t crazy for noticing the coded messages in politicians’ speeches.
Over time theories and close readings have ranged from uncovering relatively straightforward plot points to speculating that Tyrion is a time-travelling fetus. At this point there are plot points that technically have yet to be revealed in the main books but are essentially canon - like Jon Snow being the child of Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark - which are so well-established that contrarian alternative theories have sprung up.
If you pull everything together you can get a pretty good idea of how the last books are going to go. It’s not perfect - it’s all sort of fuzzy and uncertain - but I would say it borders on spoilers for unpublished books. So the wait has now become a tedious affair: not anticipation of something mysterious, but just a matter of seeing what existing literature will be confirmed and what will be upended by GRRM’s sheer contrarianism.
I have given up on seeing the end of the series. GRRM is a depressed 77-year-old who does not want to let anyone finish his saga; in the event of his death, the estate would pass to his wife, who shares these views. But until very recently I still held out some hope of one day reading Winds of Winter.
What finally brought me acceptance was wondering about that same question of another person finishing the series. Even if the estate won’t let it happen, you have to wonder who would be best to take up the mantle. I feel strongly that the most common suggestion, Brandon Sanderson, would be a terrible choice, even though he handled the ending of The Wheel of Time acceptably. Instead I’d look to people with greater thematic chops like Naomi Novik.
Now, I have a somewhat unusual relationship with Novik in that I have read (and love) most of her novels - I grew up with the Temeraire books and hold them close to my heart - but had never been exposed to her fanfiction. Which is a huge part of her output! She’s literally one of the founders of AO3. This is not some sort of personal beef with Novik; I’m just not a big reader of fanfiction usually, though I tend to enjoy it when I happen to be exposed.
This is all to say that I was sitting there a week or two ago thinking about how great Novik would be at finishing ASOIAF, completely unaware that she’s written half a million words of ASOIAF fanfiction answering that very question.
Of course it’s completely different to the book you’d get if you professionally contracted Naomi Novik to write Winds of Winter. I would totally love to read that, of course, ideally alongside GRRM’s Winds, but the fanfiction is interesting in its own way.
The best is The Pack Survives, a fix-it tale in which the thread of prophecy is not severed by Robb’s death and he solves every single plot and character issue by… uh… having sex with everyone from Daenerys1 to Jaime.
It is very good, despite the wall-to-wall sex scenes (to be fair, it is derived from ASOIAF to begin with). The main thing that struck me was how deftly Novik is able to resolve things with just a single character committed to, not even cooperation initially, but integrity. It’s a portrait in how the latter (‘honor’, here) enables the former, which then snowballs into a mutually reinforcing network where everyone lifts each other up and creates an omni-competent whole. Compared to the fractious coalitions they’re up against, like that of the Lannisters, there’s no contest.
To begin with Robb is basically just good at winning battles. He learns two other main skills: integrity and sex. This is another thing I appreciate TPS for - it’s a great portrait of masculine virtue without being weird about it. Robb’s skills complement those around him, particularly when he (and his troops) can act as the last argument protecting the fragile new society that’s coming into being around him. He does not need to suppress his drive to conquer or his genuinely malebrained sexuality, but instead learns to stoke their flames and employ them in a productive and prosocial manner. The harem he develops is the core of the peaceful society that he helps create; all of its members are enthusiastic about it, and this is a development which feels earned.
This is done in obverse with Jaime, who is handled masterfully: his whole thing, after all, is that he embodies masculine virtues on the surface but lacks true integrity, which is tearing him apart. Novik allows him to be truly redeemed by Brienne (even if he’s dragged along the whole way) and finally earn his place in the cooperative society of the North. This post, which was also how I discovered this whole thing in the first place, covers the Jaime angle more eloquently than I could.
Novik takes the time to see the best in almost every character she touches, even the overlooked or the villainous. With the entire series wrapped up in under 200k words there are of course rushed resolutions and plot threads that are dropped or shallowly resolved, but I found that I no longer cared. By the time I reached the final lines of TPS, I was free. It no longer matters what Sarella Sand is doing in Oldtown or if Barristan Selmy is going to die in Essos. I’ll still read the books if they’re ever released, of course, but I finally have a conclusion I’m satisfied with. You might say that my memetic immune system is uniquely vulnerable to fanfiction due to a lack of exposure, and you might be right, but I don’t care. You can call it wish fulfilment and you’d be completely right. Some problems are so intractable it’s better to just have a wish come true and be done with them.
Novik has cut the Gordian knot. Or it might be more accurate to say that she has flicked her wrist, and I am willing to accept she is holding a sword, and that it’s cleaved through the coils of rope in a single stroke, because I am finally ready to be free.
After thirteen years I am free and it feels amazing.
Yes, they have sex on the dragon.
↩