Listening to the wind
In My Country (2025), Thomas Ha

In Programmer Science Fiction I briefly discussed why I am often left cold by today’s fantasy and science fiction. It would be unfair to dismiss an entire field in such a manner, however; the issue deserves more detail.
A good place to start is Thomas Ha’s short story In My Country. This was well received, to say the least. It won the Hugo and Locus awards for Best Short Story this year, and was a finalist for the Nebula and World Fantasy awards.
I also think it’s a didactic, unambitious story that has nothing new to say and never rises above competence. Most damningly, it fails to live up to its own ideal of ambiguous, internally complex art.
In My Country is about authoritarianism and ambiguity. The protagonist is a father living in a fictional regime; he watches his children grow up in a closely surveilled society where people enjoy broad, if circumscribed, freedoms. There is one overriding directive, however: everything must be clear. Criticism of the regime is tolerated as long as it is unambiguous. People are constantly being disappeared to camps or executed—the “far fields”. The regime is in many ways more oppressive than those of the 20th century due to its use of omnipresent digital surveillance and profusion of political officers. These officers, who reside in blue houses, can and do intrude into each citizen’s home at all hours.
Our protagonist’s son becomes an author and writes a series of ambiguous tales that undermine the regime. He’s sent to the far fields for this offence, which radicalises the protagonist’s daughter, leading her to kill the neighbourhood political officer and join a resistance organisation. The story closes with seeds of doubt beginning to sprout in the protagonist’s heart as he learns to sit with ambiguity. In the background, it’s implied that the regime is struggling and is close to collapse.
In My Country is pretty good. It’s written well on a technical level, with clipped prose that conveys the effects of a lack of ambiguity on the mind of the narrator. Ha does some good work fitting his plot between the lines, since the story must be told in the gaps of what our narrator is willing to admit to himself.
I would have liked more from the narrator’s psychology, but he’s well sketched nevertheless, and the profiles of the political officers and the “First Citizen” are one of the story’s strengths.
Small flourishes, like the way the political officers are described as “listening to the wind”, build a wonderfully melancholy atmosphere. Ha evokes a world of clean sidewalks and cloudless skies that is nevertheless missing a fundamental part of life.
However, you do good steel no favours by striking lightly.
My first issue is that Ha is irritatingly direct in a way that is not attributable to his narrator. Ironically this story is all about ambiguous art, but is not particularly layered or complex itself. It’s also inconsistent in how much it expects of its readers. There are several crucial scenes where it leaves the reader to make connections or interpret things for themselves, but it also has many sentences that imply something and then immediately spell it out. A couple of examples:
One day, over Sunday supper, my children said the usual prayers for their mother (who was no longer with us, like many mothers who were no longer with us after the closure of the state hospitals).
A man with a crooked nose walked through our neighborhood. The crooked nose was bent at the bridge, indicating it had been broken several ways, long ago.
Or take one of the son’s ambiguous tales:
…he wrote a story that did not feel so outlandish. It was about a sickness. It was about a sickness that made chickens turn black and limp in their cages. It turned their feathers into flecks of dried skin and their eyes into weeping sores. When people ate the chickens, they would feel unwell, shut themselves in their homes, and never emerge.
Someone who worked with the chickens on the farm tried to warn his village, and other villages, against eating them. But someone with a long rope, someone called the Rope Man, paid the worker a visit before he could get very far or tell any of the others about the chickens. The story did not end. The story did not end, but it stopped abruptly, when the Rope Man paid the worker a visit.
In My Country also repeats itself; this is partly a side effect of its sparse style, but Ha leans on it enough that I found it grating. There are several bits of dialogue that essentially consist of people repeating phrases back at each other. I appreciate this is an intentional effect, but that doesn’t mean I like it.
It’s interesting to compare this story with one of Naomi Kanakia’s tales, like This billionaire destroyed a publishing company, which are told in a similar style to In My Country. From the title you might expect that Kanakia’s story is much more direct and has fewer layers to its narrative—particularly considering that ambiguity is not her main focus and she is not operating with the constraint of Ha’s authoritarian society, which forces the addition of at least one narrative layer.
But the opposite is true. This billionaire… has real ambiguity in a way In My Country lacks; Kanakia doesn’t come out clearly in favour of one side of her conflict, and instead leaves the reader to form their own conclusions. In contrast, Ha adopts a hectoring tone even though he knows he’s preaching to the choir. This billionaire… has more to unpack below the surface, whereas In My Country would be exhausted by a second or third close reading.
In My Country also takes shots at other kinds of writing. These are unjustified and baffling, since often Ha seems to be attacking his allies against authoritarianism.
For instance, the son rejects any possibility of a positive vision:
Can you write nicer stories? Nicer worlds?
I write things I can imagine, he said. I can’t create things I could never possibly imagine.
The narrator discusses the compelled punditry of the regime in a way that comes across as a dig toward real-world mainstream media:
Between the day-work ending bell and the night-work starting bell, we watch many men and women discuss the country and its officials on our televisions. They are free to say good things and bad things. So long as they pick one or the other. The important thing is to be sure to pick one or the other and talk to fill the time. When you fill the time with talk, there is little time for unproductive contemplation and other small ruins.
And the son again, on the importance of writing itself:
Experiences matter. Actions matter. But words are only signifiers, means, for both. They are not an end in themselves. I don’t write words because of the words.
This one is more ambiguous, but it leaves a bad taste in my mouth; it’s too dismissive of the poetic and aesthetic projects in literature, and disregards the words themselves as an action (Orwell and Didion were both interested in words-as-action, for instance). This section felt like a reductive statement of the words-as-symbols school of thought from Aristotle to Tolstoy.
I also find it interesting to think about how real dissidents would read these stories. In this case, I think Soviet samizdat readers would find In my Country dull. It doesn’t tell them anything new and its conclusion is an aphorism; ambiguity is cold comfort for someone actually facing down food shortages and the KGB. It doesn’t crackle with nervous energy like the best samizdat, and it isn’t funny. It simply lacks the sauce. You would think the setting would lend itself to sexual undertones, for instance, but these didn’t come through for me—though Ha, to his credit, does gesture in this direction.
So why did Ha—an American—write this particular story?
We can assume he felt the subject matter was particularly important. We can assume, too, that In My Country was intended to reflect on Ha’s society; while competent, it has nothing new to say about authoritarianism, digital surveillance, and so on. It’s a cleanly executed reassertion of principles.
I dislike how Ha gestures towards societies like the US throughout In My Country. The project of defending and developing a liberal society is more complex (more ambiguous, you might say) than that of resisting a strawman of an authoritarian regime. “No kings” is a pithy political slogan but not a policy programme. And I’d resist trite comparisons that equate the Trump administration with Ha’s regime—there are so many differences that this analogy makes one worse, not better, at thinking about contemporary politics.
Ha’s focus is also misguided. I agree that defending liberalism is an important project. But In My Country still has an impoverished vision of speculative fiction. It does not reach for anything new—in this sense it’s almost reactionary. It certainly does not engage with the frontiers of science or technology, or dig into the loam of the human subconscious present in mythology. It does not use its speculative-fiction elements to reach a perspective on the human condition that realism cannot.
In some sense my issues with In My Country have nothing to do with Ha. He’s written a well-crafted story about something important to him: would that we could all be so lucky. But this is a story to read once, take note of its nicer flourishes, and move on. I don’t mean to single this story out: it has much to recommend it, but it’s a good example of why I am so often dissatisfied with its ilk.
The fact that stories like In My Country now dominate flagship speculative fiction awards is disquieting. We live in a period of intense technological turmoil. New fields of experience are blooming. We are in desperate need of work that grapples with the present as it is, that rises to the occasion of the decade, that has the ambition and scope to confront the new worlds we are creating.
This work is being produced (here’s a few examples) but does not receive mainstream attention. I know that the speculative fiction community can raise its ambitions and simultaneously achieve artistic, commercial, and critical success; it has before and will again.
Instead we have an establishment that is content to retreat from the challenge and focus on comforting the comfortable.