What it takes to build a world
Planet (2025) and how the tech right differs from Futurism

Why can’t the tech right produce good art?
Intuitively, this might not seem like an interesting question. You simply wouldn’t expect the sort of people that populate the tech right to possess the necessary reflectivity and sensitivity. But it has happened before: the Italian Futurists produced a lot of great material. So what are the key differences between these two subcultures, and how are they expressed in art?
To motivate this discussion it helps if we focus on a single example: the short film Planet (2025), from Story Inc.
Planet is a science fiction tale set in a retrofuturistic world: not the retrofuture of the Jetsons, but one of Instrument Serif, suspenders, and San Francisco cocktail bar aesthetics. It centres on a project to build an artificial planet—a vast, spherical supercomputer whose surface will be terraformed for human habitation. We follow the visionary who leads the project, a Dr. Khan, as he struggles to realise his dream. The work takes centuries. Khan repeatedly enters and exits cryosleep, growing old as the work shades towards completion despite ruinous setbacks. His final awakening is a bittersweet one. His right-hand man, Grease, is dead: his life was spent shepherding the final stages as Khan slept. Khan had been left undisturbed so that he might see the project completed. We close on Khan standing alone on the surface of his Planet at last, running his fingers through the virgin soil.
Some context is in order. Planet is a product of the Gundo. This is a subculture based in the town of El Segundo, a beachfront slice of Los Angeles jammed in next to an oil refinery. A few steering vectors to get you into the latent-space neighbourhood: Reindustrialize, American Dynamism, hard tech, deep tech, defence tech, Christ is King, bench press, giant wall-covering flags, hard science fiction, Zyn, Corvette, Porsche, CNC machining, cigars, raw milk. All of this is somewhat contrived: the Gundo’s leaders are aware of the need to cultivate a coherent, attractive aesthetic.
The man behind Planet and Story Inc. is Jason Carman, who started out filming high-quality podcast interviews with various startup founders around San Francisco. Carman was originally associated with SF hardware firms like the satellite company Astranis, and has migrated to focus on the Gundo scene. The SF tech industry doesn’t pay the Gundo much attention, but San Francisco looms large in the minds of the Gundo’s warriors: it’s a land of soft-handed liberal Eloi typing away on MacBooks, of unserious people who take themselves too seriously, of fake companies looting the social commons for profit. The names of prediction-market firms like Kalshi are synonyms for the Devil in El Segundo.
So. Is Planet good?
I wouldn’t call Planet slop, but it’s the opposite of artistically ambitious. It’s technically and maybe culturally ambitious, but Carman’s main inspiration is George Lucas, and he’s explicitly aiming at mass appeal. To much of the tech world, culture is a machine you can steer, and it should be aimed at high-penetration, lowest-common-denominator audiences to have as much impact as possible. Their Great Man view of history does not extend to the arts. They ‘know’ that to influence culture you need to start at the top, but their upper-middle-class mindset prevents them from internalising this. ‘Great design’ is something you pay someone $300k a year to do in Figma. And it shows up in your metrics. Anduril is obsessed with Helvetica, the flagship font of liberal, modernist globalism.
If somebody with the vision and talent of the Futurists showed up in San Francisco or the Gundo, what would happen? First of all, they’d get strange looks. They would seem too focused on ‘vibes’ and scan as potential grifters; the social commons quality index in SF is at 1996 Hangzhou particulate levels.
The tech right is also afraid of ambitious art because it doesn’t understand it. It exists outside of their pragmatically technical and naively optimistic frame. This isn’t meant to be derogatory; I think the frame has a lot to recommend it, but it should be consumed in moderation. Great art has a lot of power, which they feel but can’t fully articulate. In hardware engineering, forces you can feel but not model are bad news.
How would those Futurists react to Planet? I think they would love the way it’s jam-packed with cameos from El Segundo CEOs, but dislike the way these guys are all subordinated to Khan, Carman’s old-man protagonist. There is a lot of demand for this father figure that Carman creates. Gundo leaders are trying to step into this role, but most of them are still quite young. They don’t have anyone else: Elon Musk and Palmer Luckey are lethally effective middle-aged kids, and the Gundo hates current institutions. Liberal father figures exist as a diffuse resource in the aerospace industry (e.g. robotbeat), but not as a cultural force.
Ironically, the Gundo is more intellectually aligned with the CCP than with the Futurists—neo-Confucianism, 100-year planning, involution as an end in itself. From the perspective of the Futurists this yearning for institutions, responsibility, and elder guidance is cucked. But what distinguishes them from the CCP, this streak of individual vitality, is Futurist-coded. You can see some of this in the way that the project is framed. The Planet is a vast supercomputer, but this computing power is to be harnessed to expand the capabilities of unaltered humans. Even though Planet takes place over centuries of future history, there is no sense that humanity is under threat of replacement or sublimation by its own technology. In Carman’s ideal society, Man is always master of his creations.
The distinction between Gundo and Futurist is easiest to illustrate with an example. Take:
a) Someone who baits cops on his motorcycle at 150 mph and posts the footage to YouTube.
b) A short-sleeved button-down, middle-aged father, Lockheed organization man working in the Skunk Works.
The Futurists exalt the former and disdain the latter, whereas El Segundo exalts the latter and disdains the former.
The most striking section of Planet is its middle third, in which a tiny mishap, an overlooked bit of quality control, causes three vast structural plates to collide. The following scene juxtaposes Khan being cross-examined by bureaucrats who control his funding with an internal meeting in which he excoriates a subordinate responsible for the failure. I encourage you to watch this section for yourself. It’s fresh and confronting. Khan tells his subordinate, “You should be on your knees, apologising”; he forces him to tell the whole room “I’m pathetic”, and fires him. In the following scene he threatens Grease, who hired the responsible manager. Grease responds, reasonably, that he has given his entire life to the project. Khan’s answer: “Give more.”
I am with the Gundo on this one. My least favourite aspect of Futurism is its lack of respect for infrastructure, for the thankless and plodding work that keeps the wheels of civilisation turning—or pushes it forward. The dynamic Carman depicts is very real, but it’s something that media tends to shy away from, both for its brutality and because few artists understand what it’s like inside these engineering organisations. I am not an American or a Christian, but my day job is in one of these grubby corners of the world-machine where tiny errors kill people. Pressurised liquid nitrogen does not care about work-life balance or whether it was technically someone else’s job to torque the bolts down.
Planet is cold-eyed and brutal, but so is physics. This should not be the way our entire society works, regardless of what the Gundo would prefer; it’s a good thing that liberalism has created many idyllic pockets. But some people need to be held to this standard. And I feel the pull of responsibility, the desire to be asked to rise to the challenge, for someone to sit me down and say: you have not yet truly lived. Give more.
But even though I am sympathetic to Planet’s message—and I think this message is unique—I still don’t think it succeeds as art. It lacks the ambiguity of great science fiction; it treats the human psyche as something to be trampled or managed rather than an end in itself. For all their faults, the Futurists were not like this. They could, and did, produce real art. The tech right struggles to present an attractive, new, broad-based vision. Fundamentally they wish for people to knuckle down and return to old patterns, to Just Try Harder. This may work for some, but it forecloses the possibility of artistic (though not commercial!) success for Carman.
What is needed for the creators of Planet is not to give more, but to move in new directions, to tease at the threads of the movement in the areas that seem most promising. Few projects are worth the cost of one’s life.