Huge DarknessSam T. Oates

In another life

The Everlasting (2025), Alix E. Harrow

Knight’s Tournament (1912), Zygmunt Ajdukiewicz

Love is more real than reality. It is an intensely personal experience, a psychedelic dose with a half-life of decades that seems to distort the bounds of space and time.

This is the beating heart of The Everlasting, winner of the 2026 Hugo for Best Novel; it’s a perfect example of how fantasy and science fiction can explore ideas in ways inaccessible to realist fiction. Its internally consistent secondary world and metaphysics makes literal the experience of romance and how its ripples distort the world.

Everlasting focuses on a trio of characters: historian Owen Mallory, ruler Vivian Rolfe, and the titular knight Una Everlasting. These descriptions are deliberately vague. The core of the novel is a yew tree, sprouted from the cold heart of a dragon, which allows a person to travel through time. Each of the main cast takes on a plethora of roles and identities throughout as they shift from era to era, the scenery and their relationships rearranging themselves in non-linear jumps.

The setting is Dominion, a fascist analogue of Britain that has transitioned from feudalism to a twentieth-century state of modernity. We meet it at the opening of the novel in its modern guise, a place of smog, children’s deft hands flickering in munitions factories, ruddy-cheeked propaganda, and a perpetual war economy. Owen is a struggling academic, discriminated against for his foreign heritage and disfigured by time in the army, competing for a single faculty posting in his period of historical expertise.

This faculty job exists for its value to the regime. The idea is to manufacture historical narratives, mining Dominion’s history for propaganda to inspire the troops of the present. Owen is a little conflicted about this, but when he’s offered the chance to produce the first translation of a newly uncovered primary source, The Death of Una Everlasting, he jumps at the chance. It helps that Owen has been strangely obsessed with Una (a sort of Arthurian, dragon-slaying Grail knight figure) since childhood. But this straightforward frame narrative falls apart within pages; the “primary source” is blank and Vivian, the new Minister of War, sends Owen back in time to Una’s side to write the chronicle firsthand, retrocausally penning the founding myth of his fascist society in the process.

Things only escalate from there. This is just the first of Everlasting’s dizzying gyres. We expand from the core loop of Una’s quest, which always leads to her death, into Owen’s recognition that he has been doing this for a very long time. He falls in love with Una—or, more accurately, remembers that he has always been in love with her—and begins to fray mentally as he continually fails to save her. The second act heralds the introduction of the true conflict. Una’s Queen Yvanne and Owen’s Minister Vivian are the same person. Vivian is herself a time traveller and has single-handedly created Dominion, ruling it with a succession of identities for a reign lasting centuries. Owen and Una are merely two of her most useful tools, honed over thousands of iterative timelines into tools for crafting historical narratives. If Una and Owen are to achieve lasting happiness, they must overcome Vivian and topple the historical edifice that is Dominion.

This is by no means the entire book—trust me when I say that the third act is much crazier than you’re imagining—but by the end of the second all the key elements are established.

On a mechanical level, it’s incredibly impressive how Harrow manages such a complex orchestra of a book. Everlasting has a ridiculous amount going on for a single novel, yet this never overwhelms the reader or seems to escape Harrow’s control. I feel her background as a historian is important here; she’s able to methodically set up and expand the narrative through level after level while keeping each engaging. I was hooked by Owen’s initial frame narrative, but I didn’t feel let down as this was cast aside and the scope expanded. It’s fascinating to read fiction that literalises the historian’s skill of being able to write about a period at so many scales, from the intensely personal to the fate of nations.

Another reason this works is Harrow’s deft use of images and symbols. If you return to Owen’s opening chapters before any time travel even takes place you realise that the whole novel is there in microcosm: the whole cast, the central relationship between Owen and Una, and the process of manufacturing Dominion’s synthetic history. There are also a variety of concrete images that recur like wayposts at each level of the plot, most notably the magical yew tree that Owen and Una (and eventually Vivian) return to like a lodestone. Una’s last words as she dies are always the same: “Meet me under the yew tree.”

The yew is a masterful bit of imagery to hang the narrative around. Many real churchyards in Britain have yew trees that are hundreds of years old which have witnessed successive eras of history transform the land around them. The original purpose of these yews is ambiguous—were they a centre of pagan ritual or a mark of initial Christian consecration? All of this symbolic context is imported and used masterfully by Harrow. The yew/you resonance isn’t left on the table, either: some might find this cheesy, but I think Harrow barely avoids falling into this trap.

There are many delightful details. For instance, Owen received a throat injury during the war that keeps him from ‘speaking clearly’ - both to Una and in the way he constructs historical narratives. And each time Rolfe sends him back in time she stabs him in the sinistral—left—hand to provide the blood required for the time-travel ritual to activate. This simultaneously spares his writing hand, calls to mind a mark on the sinistral side of a coat of arms (signalling illegitimacy), and creates literal overwritten scar tissue with each loop.

The time-travel mechanics are similarly freighted with mythological symbols and never nailed down precisely. Primer this is not, but that’s fine; you’re here for the literary effects of Harrow’s alternate metaphysics. Besides, with everything going on you don’t have time to pause and tease at inconsistencies. The pacing is breakneck yet Harrow is able to give the reader space to breathe with timeskips and deft narration. I never felt rushed even though the novel barely crams its plot into its generous page count.

The Everlasting could not succeed as a novel without a strong relationship between the two romantic leads. Thankfully, this is one of its most successful elements.

First of all, it avoids several pitfalls. Fantasy romance is packed with novels where the fantastical metaphysics creates a world which is warped around the relationship of the leads—”my pairing with the prince of the fae court was prophesied for centuries and is the only thing that can stop the world falling into darkness!”

This is fun, but it does away with much of the tension inherent in real romance for the sake of narcissistic wish fulfillment. In contrast, Owen and Una’s relationship is central but still secondary to a metaphysics that is centred around the process of constructing historical narratives. The struggle against Vivian creates stakes that are independent of the success of the central romance. This greatly strengthens Everlasting: I was more invested in the romance due to the extreme circumstances it was being pursued under.

Secondly, it would have been easy to mishandle the slow burn up to the ‘beginning’ of Owen and Una’s relationship. They already have so much history with each other that it’s hard to balance foreshadowing with maintaining a genuine sense of freshness and ambiguity. Harrow threads this needle successfully, mostly through deft use of Owen’s relationship with Una as a historical icon. He thinks he’s obsessed with her in a parasocial way, like a fan’s relationship to a K-pop idol, but we (and him) come to realise that this is the reflection of something much more personal. Because there’s so much uncertainty from Owen’s perspective in the first act, Harrow is able to create will-they-won’t-they tension around the relationship of the leads, even as she makes it clear that they are connected by something stronger than fate. Owen at first believes he loves Una as a symbol of the society he so desperately wishes to win the approval of—this is, of course, exactly backwards.

This is one way in which the time-bending metaphysics of Everlasting is necessary to the success of its unique romance. But it’s not the primary thrust. Instead, the time travel is primarily deployed to paint a picture of Owen and Una’s relationship as one maintained between a succession of individuals, a covenant that these individuals are nevertheless devoted to. This is an approach taken previously in This is How You Lose the Time War and The Time Traveller’s Wife—not to mention Reasons and Persons. It’s a beautiful depiction of the experience of a long relationship; for Owen and Una it is shared context and ‘time under tension’ that matters more than their disparate initial selves. And though they never quite find peace, they make the most of what they have. As within, so without. I will marry next year after a seven-year relationship; the romance Harrow sketches resonated with me in a way few have.

Finally, it is worth noting that Everlasting contains some interesting handling of gender roles. Una and Owen avoid the obvious route of simply gender-swapping their personalities. Una is not a ‘masculine woman’; rather, she sheds much of her humanity and with it her femininity in a misguided pursuit of duty. The honed core that remains is distinctly feminine. Meanwhile, Owen is a creature of masculine virtue strangely expressed, damaged and insecure about not living up to Dominion’s rigid gender roles. The two are more like a pair of battered shields whose dents and divots happen to fit together perfectly.

The other primary purpose the novel’s metaphysics is put to is its commentary on history. Harrow presents the construction of narrative while simultaneously participating in events as the fundamental experience of history; Dominion is not unique, nor is this process escapable, but it does matter who controls the narrative. This elevates The Everlasting above its contemporaries like Time War, which despite its premise seems to care very little about history. This is not to single out Time War; Everlasting is the exception in a niche that seems to treat history as an eye-catching backdrop. Favourable associations are brought to mind with classics like Doomsday Book.

One side effect of the novel’s historical competence is its handling of fascism. The “present day” of dominion is unequivocally fascist, but this is handled with a defter touch than most modern fantasy. Everlasting contrasts with books like Metal from Heaven in that it does not present a strawman of authoritarianism to knock down, a system that is only seen from outside in its external effects and impressions. Owen begins Everlasting deeply enmeshed in his society. He’s even served with distinction as a soldier, having rebelled against his liberal father in his youth. Owen is never a full-throated fascist, but has a believably complicated relationship with the regime. His love for Una means the propaganda stirs his heart more than most, and he wishes he could live up to the ideal of a Dominion man. He’s willing to overlook the cynical nature of a faculty appointment in history for the opportunity to work on what he loves. In his heart he knows he’ll be nothing more than a propagandist, but he twists himself into knots of motivated reasoning to justify this selfishness.

Una is similarly devoted to her Queen Yvanne, though in an uncomplicated sort of Arthurian-fealty way. This makes sense, both for her period and for her more masculine and straightforward approach to duty, but it means she suffers in comparison to Owen. Like many romance novels, Everlasting tells its tale using chapters that alternate between Owen and Una’s perspectives. I found Owen consistently more interesting. There’s the aforementioned greater depth to his character, but he’s also more fun to read and possesses a stronger voice than the stoic Una.

Overall, The Everlasting is not without flaw. It hesitates and grates here and there, and its central romance—while good—is not the best I have ever read. But it is still well-deserving of its Hugo. It is heartening to see such excellent work still succeeding in the mainstream spaces of science fiction. And more broadly it is heartening to see genre fiction still demonstrating the need for its existence, its ability to step outside what is possible for realism and illuminate our own lives from delightful new angles.