Three neglected issues
Gynaecology, emergency food, and transformers

One of the lodestars of the Effective Altruism movement is the ITN framework for evaluating cause areas: Importance, Tractability, and Neglectedness. You want to focus on issues that are high-impact, that you can make progress on, and that people aren’t already pursuing.
EAs are ruthlessly dedicated to identifying cause areas using this, and I have nothing to add to the mainstream discussion. However, there are three issues that fit this description which I think deserve more mindshare.
1. Endometriosis
Gynaecological health is hardly obscure, but it’s always seemed strange to me that society doesn’t put more resources into it. The burden is enormous and broad-based. It’s debilitating for millions of women who experience regular episodes of severe pain. The process of diagnosis is a Kafkaesque nightmare in which one attends appointments for years on end, endures Biblical levels of gaslighting, and is eventually told that no one understands the disease anyway and that there is no real treatment. Which is true. The field is basically preparadigmatic!
The solution seems simple. This is a clear R&D problem that needs a well-funded Focused Research Organisation pointed at it; while you’re at it you might as well attack adjacent issues like PCOS and adenomyosis. There is an enormous market for solutions, so as soon as we figure out the basic biology then big pharma can take up the torch. The NIH has historically spent ~tens of millions on endometriosis annually, a fraction of the budget for diseases with similar prevalence. A good first step would be to simply increase this number—potentially a good angle for the imminent Woke 3.
This is one way to increase birth rates without asking men or women to make sacrifices, though the effect would likely not be large.
I also see this as an excellent first target for AI biology efforts, if there are real capabilities to exploit here. The optics would be wonderful; it’s one way the labs could demonstrate they are dedicated to realising broad-based benefits.
Arguments against. Gynaecological issues are a first world problem. It’s not worth diverting scarce resources to this when they could be spent on global health. People have already tried; it’s possible I am ignorant of the state of the field, and the reason for the lack of funding is a recognition that there are no good solutions, but articles like this make me skeptical.
2. Food resilience
Every now and then you’ll see people discussing a catastrophic event for our current food sources—a nuclear winter or an engineered plague targeting crops, for instance. The assumption is always that this means game over. We don’t have any alternatives, certainly not anything we could scale in time, and the world would starve.
But this isn’t true. In fact, there’s an obscure EA org already working on this: ALLFED. And their conclusion is that we easily have the capacity to survive the most severe imaginable shocks to the food system.
Firstly, we waste a lot of the food we grow. A third of global cereal output goes to animal feed; the US uses a lot of its corn to manufacture ethanol; and there’s slack in the form of food waste which would be taken up in any situation of scarcity.
Secondly, we have some good marginal options. Production has room to shift toward the tropics. Tuber crops like potatoes or sugar beets are remarkably cold-tolerant and mature quickly, allowing for a fast pivot. It’s also pretty simple to build greenhouses that can add a crucial few degrees of warmth. Some of ALLFED’s most interesting research is in building and testing these low-tech designs—not just greenhouses, but all sorts of emergency infrastructure including kits to convert cars into electrical generators and backyard bioreactors.
But this does not cover the most extreme scenarios in which, say, growing cereals is impossible. Even in that case, however, we have a fighting chance. We produce mind-boggling amounts of energy, most of which does not depend on things like sunlight or the health of particular wheat species, and so the problem is actually just repurposing 10% of natural gas production to produce human-edible calories. ALLFED’s proposed mechanism is growing methane-eating bacteria at scale; they have produced detailed analyses of how existing industrial plants could be converted to support this.
Seaweed farming—the ocean is an enormous heatsink, and seaweed grows well in low light—and sugars extracted from wood are secondary options. It’s surprising how much margin for error ALLFED’s analysis allows us.
One extremely important issue is avoiding export bans. ALLFED’s modelling shows that these are deadlier than actual crop losses, because many highly populated countries import most of their calories. The shock to the system is most dangerous as an excuse to defect from the current equilibrium.
ALLFED already receives carefully calibrated funding through normal EA channels, but broader attention to these issues could have some benefits. Distributed institutional capacity and prepared infrastructure globally would go a long way to mitigating the largest risks, which are mostly around the need to ramp up alternatives in a matter of months following a disaster.
ALLFED has done the legwork to demonstrate that survival is physically possible, but the fact that this knowledge is so obscure is a problem in itself. It makes overreaction and export bans much more likely, which could easily overshadow the impacts of an actual disaster.
Arguments against. ALLFED has already done the important work, and the scenarios they study are the right combination of non-existential and unlikely such that they basically aren’t worth worrying about. We have limited institutional capacity and more immediate issues deserve all our attention. Ensuring free trade and liberal internationalism survive is sufficient; there’s no need to focus on this specific issue.
3. Grid resilience
When I mention this to someone who has thought about the issue before, they tend to immediately jump to geomagnetic storms like the Carrington event. Basically, the electrical grid acts like a giant antenna during these events; the solar storm would induce massive surge currents, which would burn out critical infrastructure like transformers, sending us back to the dark ages in a few hours.
This is a good reason to worry, but it’s not the primary reason I include this section.
The main problem is just that we cannot replace high voltage transformers at all! The lead time for these things is measured in years even under normal conditions. Losing dozens at once could black out whole regions for an extended period. The solution could be as simple as a willingness for nations to spend money on global stockpiles. There are already a few programs like Grid Assurance in the US, but these must be scaled up if they are to handle a catastrophe.
Primary transformers are delicate equipment. Most have several exposed ceramic enclosures containing insulating oil; these can easily be broken by (for example) rifle bullets, rapidly leading to catastrophic arcing. Enclosures that can block sight-lines and bullets should be a no-brainer in terms of expected value.
Secondly, nations should dedicate resources to developing operational plans for handling outlier scenarios for their national grids. Most countries have done high-level surveys and tabletop exercises on scenarios like geomagnetic storms. Few, however, have an operational playbook that tells operators what steps to take and what equipment to put offline in such a situation—not to mention actually drilling these procedures. We’d only have about an hour of warning if a second Carrington event happened, so this is critical.
Thankfully a template already exists. New Zealand has already set all of this up for their national grid; other countries just need to follow suit.
One part of this system that I don’t think needs more attention is the early-warning infrastructure itself. The US just launched a highly capable new early warning system, SOLAR-1, this year.1
Arguments against. This is a broader issue that will take time to resolve; we need to target further up the supply chain. For example, we need to build more capacity for manufacturing electrical steel. Buying transformers that sit in warehouses may not actually be a good use of the marginal dollar when people are starving to death.
SOLAR-1 is amusingly managed by the NOAA, whose mission also includes space weather.
↩