Are you in or out?
Terra Ignota and the future of the culture war

People talk about how the REAL culture war is going to be between transhumans and bioconservatives. I think the motte to this bailey is illuminated by Terra Ignota. Its central conflict, between an ‘inner path’ and ‘outer path’, is deep and convincing; but how seriously should we take this as a divide? Will future politics be dominated by this?
A quick recap is in order. The philosophy of the outies (aka Utopians) is based around unbounded expansion - think technological development and space colonization, with a core philosophy that values pushing frontiers and "going down to the sea in ships" for its own sake. Meanwhile the innies (aka Gordians) see this as, well, not pointless, but think that the challenges of expanding into space are so great, and the depths of the human mind so complex, that they would prefer to focus on inner exploration - think BCIs, emulated minds, and science fictional psychology.
If you compromise you end up with two half-hearted programs that are constantly competing for resources. And Ada Palmer makes a convincing argument that one program, fully committed to, is greater than the sum of split priorities. The tails are fat.
Something else Palmer argues convincingly is that all the major ideologies present in the world today converge into one of these two camps. One of the greatest achievements of Terra Ignota is its array of extrapolated factions. These are evolved versions of 21st-century blocs that have been adapted for a post-scarcity 25th century. Palmer, despite seeming like a fairly typical American liberal herself, manages to pass about a dozen ideological Turing tests on everything from RETVRN imperialists to land-obsessed chaebols.
So far this is all seems very well worked out. But the history of science fiction is littered with well-written books whose social clockwork, though beautifully interlocked and expressing something interesting about the human condition, has basically no relation to what the future actually looks like. Often they don't just introduce some new culture war fault line, they assume that it will dominate everything else. Or, more charitably, they just want to focus on their new thing rather than complicating it with issues people are already tired of in the present.
What works have avoided this? Stand on Zanzibar is famous for its unusually accurate picture of 2010. The vibe is incredibly on point for something written in 1969 - it’s heavily influenced by McLuhan and nails both the direction and magnitude of many big questions, like the semi-stagnation of the US, the state of status games and mimetic effects of network technology, the unification but irrelevance of Europe, and the rise of China. Of course it has plenty of misses - like New York urban decay memes and supersonic airliners - and coincidences people overindex on, like a black politician called Obomi.
But Zanzibar was totally wrong.
Its eponymous1 issue is overpopulation; it’s hard to think of an issue it was possible to be more wrong about. So how did Brunner manage to get his set dressing so dialled in while focusing on the wrong question at the macro level? I think there are a few reasons, like the fact that Brunner’s new-wave intellectual milleu helped him get McLuhan quite early on while also making him put too much stock in the Club of Rome. But the pertinent one is the fact that Brunner went much further than his contemporaries in wanting to situate his central issue in a cross-section of society. He also went further in how his central issue is just one among many, shaped by its relationships to the crowded stable of other problems. This gave him the chance to be correct on peripheral issues even though his central thrust missed.
We can take a few lessons from this. It’s possible that Terra Ignota’s world is prescient in many ways while its central conflict is irrelevant. Seeds of its conflict in today’s society could be false signals.
There are also reasons from this case study to put more credence in Terra Ignota. Zanzibar is more like an intelligent elaboration of a particular worldview, and suffers for it, whereas Terra Ignota is much better at synthesising a variety of ideologies. Overall we have reasons to be skeptical, but there is also a strong case for taking Terra Ignota seriously in this regard.
Secondly, we should look backward. Does our current culture war have seeds present in earlier eras?
My impression is that we find not just seeds but full-blown cycles of discourse on the same issues stretching all the way back to the start of the 20th century. There you see people complaining en masse about the pace of society, the effects of new technology on psychology, a populace sedated and propagandized by mass media, ‘feminization’, and so on. Many a book has been written about this, but this Derek Thompson piece is a good example of what I mean. These were some of the biggest issues of the day.
It seems the right model is less of a slow widening of these fault lines but rather sudden shifts, with issues gaining immediate and permanent prominence as soon as new technology diffuses widely enough. I would expect innie/outie discourse to explode as soon as one or more of the relevant technologies cross a certain threshold of capability. These technologies include infrastructure for space exploration, human modification, AI, brain interfaces, and consciousness research; AI seems much closer to the capability threshold than the others, with space exploration and human modification in second and third.
So if Terra Ignota’s binary does say something true about the world we'd expect to see the roots of the conflict already, particularly in highly developed countries like the US that are well on their way through the development S-curve that the Hives have topped out.
I do think we see this. These coalitions seem to arise naturally from existing cultural factions.
The current innie coalition is broadly left-wing and includes much of the Silicon Valley AI culture. Rationalists, hippies, psychedelic enthusiasts, software engineers, consciousness researchers, neuroscientists, some environmentalists - particularly degrowthers - and the majority of those in the humanities make up the faction. I think innies tend towards utilitarianism, perhaps because understanding and modifying internal states is much more attractive from a utilitarian perspective. Currently there is also a bias toward materialist computationalism, but I don’t see this as load-bearing and can certainly imagine a dualist innie program.
Outies in contrast are broadly right-wing: they are people of action, working in hard-nosed industries like finance or hardware. Right wing subfactions like “based Nietzschean vitalists” are clearly part of this - Palmer aligns her RETVRN trad faction with the outies, which I think is correct. A minority of the AI community are outies. Think e/acc, the sort of people who see AI as a tool to unlock human agency and build more stuff. Spaceflight enthusiasts and most science fiction fans belong in this camp. Outies tend to be pragmatic deontologists or virtue ethicists, with an implicit bias toward enactivism.
Something Palmer doesn’t touch on is the existence of groups which decline to participate in the conflict. There are two types of these: those who reject the dichotomy for a third path, which are a small enough minority at the moment they aren’t worth mentioning, and those who don’t want to actively participate in the future.
Two examples of what I mean by the latter are luddites and wireheaders. The former rejects progress entirely and wants to go back to a pastoralist existence; the latter is happy to give up their agency in exchange for access to the experience machine.
Ada Palmer has an admirable amount of faith in humanity, but if I’m being realistic I tend to agree with Peter Watts’ vision of a world in which the majority of the population checks out into virtual lotus-eating as soon as it passes a reasonable quality threshold. Like the other factions, we see the beginning of this with capital-C Content and short form video. One could argue this forms a part of the innie faction, but I think it lacks the goal orientation that characterises the coalition.
Personally, I do see this as an important frame for thinking about social fault lines in the future - assuming these fault lines actually matter and we are not made obsolete by our own creations. I think there are clear positions and coalitions emerging, even if the participants are not currently aware of these blocs.
It would be odd for me to describe this without offering my own opinion. In short, I have outie instincts but think the innies are correct on the merits.
Another interesting aspect of Terra Ignota is how hilariously biased it is. Palmer shares my outie instincts and is aware of this; admirably, she leans into it rather than trying to avoid the issue. But I do think this means Terra Ignota’s innie case is not as strong as it could be, for example because the innies aren’t allowed to extrapolate the consequences of their great project (mind uploading) whereas the outies are with their Mars terraforming and the additional land it will create. This is despite the fact that the innies have superhuman world-modelling capabilities and spend the series thoroughly manipulating everyone else.
I lean towards innies on the merits for some peripheral reasons, like their greater philosophical sophistication and engagement with literature, but the crux of the matter is efficiency.
The guy digging through a mountain using a pickaxe is heroic but becomes a tragic figure with the arrival of excavators. So too with space colonisation, when we have the chance to focus on the inner path in the near future - and potentially develop ourselves into beings that are far better suited to the world beyond our good planet.
And there’s the matter of moral calculus. You have to put a really high premium on colonising Mars to delay immortality - though I do find it odd how Terra Ignota presents this as a tradeoff, considering the bottleneck is the time and energy of idiosyncratic vokers. To some extent, I do see the innie/outie question as a false dichotomy, though I don’t think this will prevent it becoming a wedge issue.
Terra Ignota takes a strange perspective on this. The Utopians are in some ways much more transhumanist than the Gordians: the former are working on limited human modification to physically adapt people to space, whereas the latter take a broadly bioconservative stance. However, this seems in conflict with the Gordian goal of exploring the greatest possible variety of minds.
The synthesis, as I see it, is the Gordian focus on improving the capabilities of minds wedded to the Utopian project of expansion.
Finally, is all of this quixotic? We should also consider the skeptical perspective on SF as predictive at all, from Ken Liu.
However, I think Liu aligns substantially with the conclusions of this essay - the idea that specific predictions can be wrong, but the process of myth-making is what matters, for instance.
What I would add to Liu is the idea that SF is uniquely suited to drawing these ideas out of the collective subconscious, new ideas created from new technology, and in their silhouettes tracing the cultural conflicts of the future. I don’t think any of the particular predictions of Terra Ignota will play out, but I do think the silhouettes it raises will cast long shadows.
The idea being that if you crammed the entire population of the future Earth into one place they could ‘stand on zanzibar’.
↩